What has worked when trying to lose weight: motivations and mindsets
Losing weight is rarely easy, but many things can help. We spoke to people about what had worked for them. Having the right mind-set Being...
There was no one way of successfully losing weight and many of the people we spoke to emphasised how important it had been to find what worked for them. Many times this involved trying out a series of diets, weight loss programmes and lifestyle approaches until they found the right way for them. As Lina commented, ‘there’s always many ways to skin a cat’. While some people advocated ‘everything in moderation’, others found it suited them better to cut food groups out completely. People also pointed out that it was helpful to monitor their weight to check the day-day effects of changes to their diet and activity of on their weight.
Below we look at the four main ways that people found helpful in losing weight:
For some of the people we spoke to, following a prescriptive diet such as the 5:2 diet, the Keto diet or Rosemary Conley system provided a helpful way to structure their weight loss plans. Shirley had been a yo-yo dieter but said she and her husband found the 5:2 diet quite successful: ‘if I was going to look at a diet again at the moment, 5:2 would probably be the one I’d go back to look at because it was very interesting having those two days quite restricted, but the rest of it was quite flexible, and I think that’s the way life is these days. You’ve got to have something that’s really flexible’. When she was working full time, Meeka found the Rosemary Conley system easy to follow because all the information came in one pocket size book: ‘It says what 1200 calories is for me, which I need, so I found that useful’.
Several people like Joan, June X, Hilary and Tommy were referred by their GPs to local NHS weight management services or other locally-run healthy living initiatives. These classes and programmes had been a good source of motivation and knowledge. For instance, Tommy participated in two community based health initiatives in his city and feels that he has been provided with (a) more information about food, including how to read the nutritional information on packaging (b) an ability to change what he eats, and (c) the confidence to try new methods of cooking. [see ‘Local and national NHS/charity support for weight management specifically for people with chronic conditions‘].
Slimming World and Weight Watchers are commercially run programmes which help people lose weight by providing face-face support meetings, weekly weigh-ins and diet plans. Those who found them successful talked about the benefits of face-face and online support, being made accountable to themselves and other people, and receiving tips and information about how to lose weight [see ‘Weight Management groups‘].
Some people spoke of the success they had had by switching to a healthier lifestyle, rather than thinking of it as a diet. This could include cutting down on certain foods, increasing fruit and vegetable intake, decreasing portion sizes and exercising more.
Some of those we spoke to had experience of losing weight following a medical intervention. Having been unsuccessful in her attempts to lose weight through other means, at the age of 49, Janet had a gastric band fitted. Now aged 62, she has lost about 10 stone.
People who had successfully lost weight had usually developed strategies to help. Distraction techniques to cope with cravings worked well for Kate who said she could distract herself on her phone or computer until the craving passed.
Losing weight is rarely easy, but many things can help. We spoke to people about what had worked for them. Having the right mind-set Being...
People often try a variety of ways to lose weight with varying levels of success. In this section, we explore what people said had not...