Deciding whether to see, hold and name the baby

Many parents may not know whether they want to see and hold the baby. They may fear that they’re going to respond badly to the baby’s abnormalities; they may dread seeing something strange and finding themselves unable to cope. Some may just want to ‘move on’ and treat the experience like a miscarriage. Deciding how to handle the situation is a matter of personal choice – as one woman said, ‘it’s just a very personal thing and there’s no right or wrong, it’s just what’s right for you.’

The first sight of the baby prompted many emotions in parents, though in general most people were more affected by the baby’s fragility and tiny size than by his/her physical abnormalities. Many were reassured that the baby looked peaceful; others felt relieved that the baby’s diagnosis had been right and that they hadn’t ended a healthy pregnancy. Some babies including those with Down’s syndrome looked – as one woman put it – ‘like any baby, but very small’. Several people described their babies as ‘perfect’ and ‘beautiful’ and were profoundly moved by what they saw.

He was very moved by the sight of his daughter and felt relieved that the doctors’ diagnosis was…

Age at interview 41

Gender Male

View profile

She felt worried about her baby’s possible disfigurement and wasn’t sure at first whether or not…

Age at interview 37

Gender Male

View profile

She wanted to treat her baby with respect and was glad she decided to see him.

Age at interview 43

Gender Female

View profile

Although sometimes parents are encouraged by health professionals to see the baby, people made different choices. Most people who decided to see the baby found it helped them accept what had happened, though one woman said it triggered guilt for her.

One or two women had not wanted to see the baby initially – one woman said it wouldn’t help her at all and declined to see the baby – another woman had seen her baby because she was advised to, and had mixed feelings about whether it helped her. Whether or not to see and hold the baby could become an issue between couples – several women we talked to said that their partners were unsure about whether they wanted to see the baby.

She had the impression that she should see her baby but found she was shocked by aspects of her…

Age at interview 38

Gender Male

View profile

One woman who had ended two pregnancies decided, against advice, not to see her first baby because she ‘didn’t want to make a big deal’ of it, and she later regretted her decision. With her second termination she decided to see the baby and was shocked by her appearance, but said that it had been the right thing for her to do.

Explains how when she ended her first pregnancy she decided not to see or hold the baby.

Age at interview 40

Gender Female

View profile

Describes seeing her second baby and how even though the baby didn’t look as she hoped, the…

Age at interview 40

Gender Female

View profile

Many parents expected the baby to be ‘baby-like’ and were shocked by his/her dark red colour and almost-transparent skin. Several women wished they had been better prepared for the baby’s appearance. Most babies were very small – anything from 2 to 4 lbs depending on his/her gestational age – which made several women worry about holding them.

Some women had seen the baby after the birth, but felt even more strongly in a day or two of leaving hospital that they needed to see the baby again. Some women wanted reassurance that the baby was being cared for properly, others just wanted another chance to be with the baby and were very grateful to staff for making it possible.

She felt guilty that she hadn’t said goodbye properly to her baby so contacted the bereavement…

Age at interview 34

Gender Female

View profile

Decided she wanted to see her baby after she had left hospital and felt much happier once she had…

Age at interview 31

Gender Female

View profile

Babies with visible external abnormalities were generally carefully dressed by midwives or wrapped up in a shawl so that parents saw them at their best. Most parents were grateful this was done – though several felt midwives took too long cleaning and dressing the baby – because it helped them accept the baby. Others had disliked seeing their babies dressed up in special clothes (see ‘Going through labour and birth’).

Holding and touching the baby

Parents made different choices about holding and touching the baby. Some parents felt that looking was as far as they could go, and appreciated not being encouraged to make more physical contact with the baby than they felt they could manage. Many people felt that seeing and holding the baby was intensely personal and that people’s feelings should be respected. Several women said their partners had definitely not wanted to hold the baby.

Explains why she decided not to hold her baby after she was born.

Age at interview 39

Gender Female

View profile

Other women felt that physical contact with the baby was essential and helped to release pent-up feelings of sadness. Some women held their babies for hours – cuddling and talking to them sometimes through the night.

Describes how she instinctively wanted to hold and touch her baby and explains how she and her…

Age at interview 37

Gender Female

View profile

Describes how she held her baby all night and talked to her about what had happened and why.

Age at interview 37

Gender Female

View profile

Several women said they slept overnight in hospital with the baby in the same room, and one couple put the baby between them in the hospital bed and had fallen asleep.

Naming the baby

Parents felt differently about whether to name the baby and how they wanted it done, if at all. Sometimes parents asked the hospital chaplain to name the baby when they said prayers or gave a blessing, sometimes parents decided they wanted to wait a while before they decided about a name. Sometimes babies were named at private naming ceremonies or at funerals or cremations (see ‘Saying goodbye to the baby’). Several people said they didn’t want to give the baby a name because they felt that the baby hadn’t really ‘lived’.

Occasionally couples disagreed about whether or not to name the baby, and several women said that they had assigned the baby a name anyway. One man said how important it was to him to be able to name his son after his father and to have heard his son’s name called out in synagogue. One man explained why he felt differently from his wife about naming the baby but was happy for her to go ahead.

Naming both the babies was important to his wife but he had his own way of remembering them.

Age at interview 45

Gender Male

View profile

Clearly not everyone we talked to had been able to see the baby – those who ended the pregnancy around 13 weeks and had had a surgical termination were unable to see or hold their babies. And a woman who had had a selective reduction of her pregnancy (she was expecting twins, one of whom had Down’s syndrome) was unable to see or hold her baby because he had not been born which she found difficult (see ‘Ending the pregnancy surgically’).

Going through labour and birth

Going through labour and birth without the reward of a healthy baby at the end is likely to be a difficult experience for most women....