What has worked when trying to lose weight: motivations and mindsets

Losing weight is rarely easy, but many things can help. We spoke to people about what had worked for them.

Having the right mind-set

Being in the right place emotionally and having the right mind-set was a prerequisite for losing weight according to some of the people we spoke with. ‘Being in the right place’ gave people the motivation and commitment to make healthy choices about food and exercise. Before she broke her shoulder, Ellie was following a low carb diet. After the accident, she was in so much pain that she couldn’t think straight, couldn’t cook and felt the diet was too much. She said, ‘You’ve got to be in the right frame of mind to do a diet like that’. For Sue Y, ‘it’s all in the mind. Yeah, your attitude does have to change if you want to lose weight’. Kate successfully lost weight and said this was partly due to the fact that she was in a happy and stable period in her life.

Having stability in her life helped Kate lose weight. She also had distraction strategies to help her beat cravings, and was encouraged by other people’s positive feedback.

Age at interview 49

View profile

Confidence to tell others about her dieting, and their support, has helped Shirley to be in the right mind-set to stick to the plan. When younger she felt embarrassed talking about it.

Age at interview 49

View profile

Part-time work and retirement have provided people like Julie and Joan with the time and the emotional space needed to tackle their weight.

Having a focus or motivation

Among the people we spoke to there were different experiences of how to get into the right mind-set. David was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes and high blood pressure around 15 years ago, but started taking his weight loss more seriously after being warned by his diabetic nurse that his health was in danger: ‘I needed a shock to start me off and to pull me back’. Angela had lost weight after having her son and while writing a novel on maternity leave: ‘having the baby and having the writing as well gave me that focus’.

Meeka was motivated to lose weight after reading a book by the Dalai Lama and Desmond Tutu.

Age at interview 66

Gender Female

View profile

The feeling of being slimmer keeps Sue X motivated and helps her avoid the temptation of cake at work.

Age at interview 49

View profile

Learning new habits

According to some, losing weight was a process which worked better with honesty and self-awareness. It could also involve re-educating oneself, and reading and learning to understand more about nutrition and weight loss. Kate did a lot of background reading and research on sugar addiction, which helped her understand the need to cut it out of her diet. Maxine Mary joined a couple of online support groups to guide her through the ketogenic diet (a low carbohydrate, high fat diet). Others simply started paying more attention to the nutritional value of their food by studying food labels in the supermarket. For example, Tommy (who had taken part in an accompanied shopping intervention) said, ‘When I go to the supermarket, I do take more note. At one time, I’d just grab whatever but I do definitely look at the colour coding and I think that has also helped’.

Julie has had the time to work out what her weaknesses are and develop coping mechanisms. Avoiding temptation is key for her.

Age at interview 73

Gender Female

View profile

Being on a weight loss programme helped Sue X feel more in control and educated about her food choices.

Age at interview 49

View profile

Counselling and psychological support

Some people talked about how counselling had helped them to lose weight. Angela suggested that counselling should be part of any weight loss programmes ‘to discuss all the issues and why they come about because, you know, I know that I was a fat baby but why there are so many chubby babies around that have grown up to not be fat? Why, why me? Why did I maintain that?’ June X felt it was ‘very necessary’ to provide long term support to people who want to lose weight. She participated in an NHS funded programme that included cognitive behavioural therapy. She found that very beneficial and said that even ‘at this incredible late stage of my life’ recording her own eating and other behaviours was ‘very effective’ [see section – Support for weight loss].

Angela felt that the Lighter Life plan worked best for her because it provided counselling and support tools at the maintenance level to help her ease out’ of a restricted diet.

Age at interview 49

View profile

Psychological support and recording what she eats as well as her thoughts and feelings has helped June to understand her eating behaviours.

Age at interview 70

Gender Female

View profile

Reasons for wanting to lose weight

Everyone has their own reason for wanting to lose weight. Among the people we spoke to, health featured high on the list of reasons to...