Support from health professionals

People’s relationships with health professionals can make a difference to how they cope with their condition on a day to day basis. Most people we talked to had encountered a wide range of health professionals during the course of diagnosis, treatment and management of their condition. They included hospital-based consultant specialists, nursing staff, general practitioners, counsellors and psychologists.
People’s relationships with health professionals ranged from positive and supportive encounters to extremely frustrating experiences in which people were very unhappy about the standard of card they have received. This summary aims to give a balanced account of people’s experiences but these are the stories of individuals and they are not necessarily representative.
Several people recalled specific encounters when a health professional had said something upsetting, without that professional necessarily being aware of the effect their words had had.

Being told that her problems with Crohns and fibromyalgia were in her head was infuriating for…

Age at interview 34

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 16

View profile

Those who lived in areas of London or other larger cities with a defined Jewish community mostly had encountered health professionals that were respectful and supportive of their religious and cultural requirements. Health professionals who had worked with the Jewish community were also more likely to have come across some of the rarer genetic conditions. A couple of people who had accessed healthcare in Israel and the United States commented on the cultural differences in the doctor, patient relationship. One woman thought her UK doctor disliked the fact that she was assertive in her views and asked challenging questions.

Rebecca and Aaron think the standard of care they received for their daughter with CF is…

Age at interview 34

Gender Male

View profile

Harriet feels that in Britain, patients are expected to be good listeners and do as they are told.

Age at interview 55

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 20

View profile

While most people were keen to be actively involved in their own or their child’s healthcare, some found it difficult to challenge what was considered ‘expert opinion’. A couple of people described how they had to be quietly ‘pushy’ to get the care and treatment they needed, or were encouraged by other health professionals to ‘make a fuss’ so their needs would be met. Those who considered themselves ‘outspoken’ in their interactions with health professionals were concerned that other, less vocal, patients might not get the same standard of care.

Sara pushed her GP to refer her son to a different consultant because she felt the first…

Age at interview 48

Gender Female

View profile

Jill was encouraged by another doctor to make a fuss to get the treatment she needed for her…

Age at interview 83

Gender Female

View profile

Sheila thinks she only got chemotherapy for her breast cancer because she pushed for it. She is…

Age at interview 59

Gender Female

View profile

People were aware of the benefits of building rapport with medical staff, as a good personal relationship might mean getting additional insights and treatment tips beyond what might be considered routine practice. However, several people said they had found it difficult to build rapport with one particular consultant, as hospital rotas meant they were likely to see different doctors at each occasion. There was also a fair degree of frustration about hospital appointments being changed at short notice. One patient wondered on what basis the people responsible for scheduling the appointments had made the decision that she could manage for another six weeks without seeing a consultant and thought the process should be made more transparent.

Harriet discusses the use of cold caps and hair loss. If the nurses see you as a person rather…

Age at interview 55

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 20

View profile

Cissie finds that consultants sometimes talk to her parents rather than to her.

Gender Female

View profile

Seeing different consultants all the time makes it difficult to build rapport. Sylvia wrote to…

Age at interview 74

Gender Female

View profile

Spending time in the hospital waiting room on the day of the appointment provided an opportunity to meet others with similar conditions. However, many people had to travel fairly long distances to access specialist treatments, so hospital appointments could easily turn into an all-day event. A couple of people were very positive about how the hospital had tried to accommodate their needs though, for example by arranging overnight accommodation for the parents of a girl with CF so that they would not need to travel on the Sabbath.

Gary lives 60 miles from the hospital. They will try to arrange all of his appointments for the…

Age at interview 53

Gender Male

Age at diagnosis 35

View profile

A few people had received care from health professionals with specialist psychological training such as nurse counsellors or clinical psychologists. However, a couple of people who had been keen to get such support had been unable to access it. A couple of others were lucky to find such support outside the NHS from voluntary organisations and specialist charities for their condition (see Support and support groups).

Harvey is disappointed that the doctors he has seen over the years are overly focused on…

Age at interview 63

Gender Male

Age at diagnosis 56

View profile

Caroline was not impressed by the psychologist she saw before her surgery.

Age at interview 36

Gender Female

View profile


Many people found it very helpful to be able to contact a nurse or consultant by telephone in case of minor questions or concerns arising between check-ups. Even if they had not made use of such facilities, people found it reassuring to have the option.

Simone decided to go privately for her cancer treatment. The care was excellent and 3 years later…

Age at interview 44

Gender Female

View profile

NHS treatment might include waiting around for appointments and having to travel to get tests…

Age at interview 39

Gender Female

View profile

Most people we talked to had received their medical care through the NHS. However, a couple of people also had experience of private healthcare for at least some of their treatment. People had positive and negative experiences in both systems. Private healthcare was described as a way of ‘jumping the queue’ while offering a less time-pressured environment and excellent aftercare.

Having treatment on the NHS could feel more like being processed by a large system; one woman with ovarian cancer talked about her ‘conveyor belt experience’. But despite longer waiting times and practical constraints, the NHS was praised for the level of expertise of its consultants and the dedication and caring attitude of its nursing staff.

Rivas consultant has been supportive, helpful and willing to try things.

Age at interview 34

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 16

View profile

Karin doesnt think there is a better place to be treated than her specialist hospital. The…

Age at interview 39

Gender Female

View profile

Jewish identity, rituals and observances

We asked people whether or not they thought being Jewish influenced how they experienced and managed their own or their child's health condition. Some people...

Information and support

Most people with a chronic health problem will, over time, become very knowledgeable about their condition and how best to manage it. Much more than...